The Cost of Indecision

Decision-making is one of the core responsibilities of leadership. Yet, too often, executives hesitate to make the calls that their teams are waiting for. Whether due to fear of backlash, a desire to maintain harmony or the hope that a better answer will magically appear, leaders who delay decisions create more harm than they realize.

Not making a decision is still a decision, it just happens to be one of the worst kinds. Indecision at the top cascades down, leaving teams stuck in limbo, wasting time and effort on initiatives that might never happen, leading to frustration, disengagement and ultimately, attrition.

While good leaders strive to make well-informed decisions, great leaders recognize that clarity is more important than consensus. Avoiding a decision may feel safe in the moment, but in reality, it is a slow erosion of trust, productivity and momentum.

In the end, the worst decision isn’t the wrong one, it’s the one you never made.

The Myth of Neutrality

Many executives avoid making tough calls because they don’t want to upset anyone. They believe that by delaying, they are remaining neutral and keeping their options open. In reality, every day a decision goes unmade the organization is making a choice: the choice to continue with the status quo, to let inefficiencies persist and to allow uncertainty to spread.

Consider a company in need of a restructuring. The leadership team knows changes are necessary, but they postpone action because they fear the impact on morale. What happens? Employees sense the uncertainty, rumors spread, engagement plummets and top talent starts leaving for more stable environments. The attempt to preserve harmony backfires, creating an even greater disruption than if the decision had been made earlier.

The Ripple Effects

Unfortunately, top executives often don’t see the full impact of their indecision. They may feel they are being cautious, but the reality is that their hesitation is costing the organization in ways they can’t see.

• Lost Time & Momentum – Without clear direction, work slows. Teams keep reworking the same problems, waiting for leadership to commit.


• Emotional Toll – Ambiguity creates anxiety. Employees don’t know where they stand, what to prioritize or whether their work will even matter in the end.


• Competing Efforts – In the absence of clarity, different teams make their own assumptions, often working at cross purposes.


• Missed Opportunities – Markets move fast. Companies that delay critical decisions - whether entering a new market, launching a product or restructuring - often find themselves playing catch-up.

Why Leaders Fear Making Decisions

Leaders avoid decisions for many reasons, but most of them boil down to fear:

• Fear of Backlash – Every decision has winners and losers, and no leader wants to alienate people. But trying to please everyone often results in disappointing everyone.


• Fear of Being Wrong – Perfectionism leads to paralysis. The reality is that most decisions can be adjusted later. A well-reasoned, imperfect decision is almost always better than no decision.


• The Wrong People Are Being Consulted – While seeking input is good, decision-making often gets stuck because the real subject matter experts are not involved. Layers of management distort the reality of a situation and decisions are made in a vacuum. You can’t talk to everyone, but you must make sure to talk to the people who have been directly working on the issue, if only to ensure they feel heard.


• Hope That Problems Will Solve Themselves – Spoiler: They won’t. Kicking the can down the road just makes the eventual decision harder.

The Power of Decisiveness

The best leaders aren’t the ones who make perfect decisions, they are the ones who make clear, well-communicated decisions and stand by them.

• Clarity Over Consensus – Decisions don’t require unanimous agreement. The goal is to make the best choice, not the most popular one.


• Set Decision Deadlines – Indecision thrives in open-ended discussions. Leaders should set firm deadlines for when a decision must be made.


• Involve the Right People – Seek input from the people who have been working on the problem directly, rather than relying solely on secondhand reports from management layers.


• Own the Decision & Communicate It Well – Once a decision is made, communicate it clearly. Uncertainty breeds resistance, but strong, transparent messaging builds alignment.

Creating a Decision-Making Culture

Leaders set the tone for how decisions are made. If decision-making is slow at the top, it will be slow at every level. Organizations that thrive in fast-moving environments do so because they embed decisiveness into their culture.

• Empower Teams to Make Decisions at Their Level – Reduce bottlenecks by allowing decisions to be made closer to the work.


• Reward Decisiveness (Not Just Perfect Outcomes) – Encourage action by valuing good decision-making processes rather than focusing solely on outcomes.


• Normalize Course Correction – Make it clear that decisions are not set in stone. Adjustments can be made, but stagnation isn’t an option.


• Leverage Technology for Clarity – Tools like Clarity Forge help leaders track goals, decisions and priorities to ensure alignment across teams.

Leaders don’t get the luxury of waiting for perfect conditions. The cost of indecision is too high, not just in missed opportunities but in lost trust, disengagement and organizational paralysis.

Every leader has a decision they’ve been putting off. If that’s you, ask yourself: What is really stopping me? What would happen if I made the call today?

Because in the end, the worst decision isn’t the wrong one, it’s the one you never made.

---

Our mission is to empower organizations by fostering cultures of clarity and transparency, engagement and collaboration. Through innovative tools, best practices and partnership with leaders, we strive to unlock the competitive advantages inherent in healthy organizations.